Catholics for Choice Statement on the Defeat of Proposition 1 in Idaho
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Wednesday, Nov. 4, 2026
Phone: 703-688-2410
Email: media@catholicsforchoice.org
Catholics for Choice Statement on the Defeat of Proposition 1 in Idaho
BOISE — Catholics for Choice, which represents the pro-choice Catholic majority, released the following statement in response to the results on Idaho’s Proposition 1, the Reproductive Freedom and Privacy Act:
“Catholics for Choice is disappointed that Proposition 1, which would have restored Idahoans’ right to privacy and reproductive freedom, was defeated tonight,” said Caitlin Borgmann, Co-President for Programs and Development. “Our hearts go out to the more than 110,000 Idahoans who signed to put this on the ballot, and to the organizers, partners, and advocates who worked hard to fight for the abortion access everyone deserves. We stand with all the pro-choice Catholics who shared their stories and resisted the clergy’s abuse of power.
“Since the overturning of Roe v. Wade, Idaho’s Catholic leadership has defended the state’s abortion ban, which criminalized abortion at every stage of pregnancy, prompting more than a third of the state’s OB-GYNs to leave or stop practicing. Those who continued to provide care faced wrenching choices between potential criminal liability and protecting their patients’ lives,” Borgmann continued.
“Despite the devastating consequences of Idaho’s abortion ban, the church hierarchy helped lead the campaign against Proposition 1,” said Lauren Bailey, Director of Organizing and Engagement. “Catholic teaching holds that healthcare is a basic human right and calls us to protect the most vulnerable, including pregnant people whose lives are at risk. I’m disappointed that our church leaders continue to lend their power and our money to an anti-abortion crusade. In Idaho, they used pulpits as political stages by reading statements against the measure. The Diocese of Boise even gave $300,000 to the opposing PAC. Their campaign to mislead Catholics into voting against the freedom to make conscience-based healthcare choices is religious overreach, and this harms everyone.”
“While we’re deeply disappointed, this fight has always been about more than one election. Idahoans deserve compassionate medical care and the freedom to make these deeply personal decisions for themselves. I will continue to raise my voice for reproductive freedom, because our work toward a more compassionate Idaho is far from over,” said Suzanne G., a pro-choice Catholic advocate in Rathdrum, Idaho.
“To every Catholic who followed their well-formed conscience to the voting booth, despite pressure from the bishops, we see you,” Borgmann concluded. “We stand with the people of Idaho, who deserve access to the full range of reproductive healthcare. Catholics want a church that protects the vulnerable, not one that wastes resources on anti-abortion lobbying. Catholics for Choice will continue fighting for Idahoans’ right to access care without religious or political interference.”
###
Catholics for Choice — which serves the pro-choice Catholic majority — encounters, educates, and emboldens people of faith who support reproductive freedom.